Best Car Insurance Rates in Colorado for 2023

WRITTEN BY: Julia Matseikovich


Before you get on the road in Colorado, ensure your vehicle is protected. Colorado insurance requirements outline liability limits for each driver and the proper coverage required for insurance. Here we break down everything you need to know about Colorado car insurance, how much it costs, and how to save on premiums.

Best Colorado Car Insurance Companies

With so many Colorado car insurance companies to choose from, you may wonder which agency is best. We’ve done the legwork for you and figured out Colorado’s best car insurance. Each company stands out for its customer service, premiums, and discounts. 

Cheapest Colorado Car Insurance Company: State Farm

If you want a policy that meets Colorado car insurance requirements, State Farm is the prime choice. The average State Farm policy is $452 a year, or $38 a month for minimum coverage. If you want full coverage, State Farm is still the best deal, with an average annual rate of $1,275. If you’re a current or former military member, you may find a better rate with USAA. The average minimum policy rate is $381 for eligible customers. 

  • Easy claims process
  • High customer satisfaction ratings from J.D. Power
  • A++ Financial Strength rating from AM Best
  • Lots of discounts and coverage options available
  • No option to add gap insurance to your policy
  • Premiums are on the higher side

Colorado Car Insurance Company With the Best Customer Service: GEICO

GEICO features the best customer service among the big corporate car insurance companies. GEICO scores 827 out of 1000 on the JD Power Customer Satisfaction survey for the Southeast Region in car insurance. Colorado drivers appreciate GEICO’s round-the-clock access to agents, easy claim file process, and communication regarding their car insurance. 

  • Many savings options available
  • Affordable rates for drivers with poor credit and speeding tickets on their record
  • Good customer satisfaction ratings
  • Offers accident forgiveness
  • Above-average rates for drivers with DUIs
  • Doesn't offer new car replacement, rideshare coverage, or a vanishing deductible
  • Lower-than-average bundling discount for people with GEICO auto and home policies

Colorado Car Insurance With the Best Discounts: Progressive

If you’re a budget-conscious consumer, Colorado car insurance companies have a variety of discounts to help you save on your premium. It’s possible to save up to hundreds of your policy each year. Typical insurance discounts include savings on safety equipment, a good student discount, and multi-policy savings. Progressive offers the most discounts in the state, with 16 available, and features driving-based savings. 

  • Favorable rates for high-risk drivers
  • Snapshot program helps unlock safe driving discounts
  • Wide range of discounts available
  • Mobile app available
  • Higher-than-average insurance costs for some good drivers
  • Doesn't offer new car replacement coverage
  • Snapshot program could increase rates if your driving score is low

Local and Regional Car Insurance Carriers In Colorado

Colorado has several options if you prefer to insure your vehicle with a local or regional carrier.

Acuity Insurance

Acuity Insurance offers drivers the coverages that Colorado policies must have, including liability, medical payments or personal injury, uninsured and underinsured motorists, comprehensive, and collision.

Since Colorado drivers may need more protection, Acuity offers vehicle replacement, replacement of full safety glass, medical payments (limits are automatically increased if wearing a seat belt), and uninsured motorist property damage coverage.

Colorado drivers can get discounts based on customer loyalty (including multi-policy and multi-vehicle) or for good driving, honor student, and accident prevention course enrollment.

American National Insurance

Automobile owners in Colorado are required to carry liability insurance, which covers bodily injury or property damage if the insured is at fault. 

American National Insurance also offers Colorado drivers comprehensive, collision, gap, and uninsured motorist coverage. Additional endorsements are available for Colorado drivers, such as 24-hour roadside assistance, gap insurance, and added coverage endorsement (for replacement parts to damaged vehicles).

American National offers a variety of unique discounts to its customers, like completely waiving your deductible if you’re involved in an accident with another vehicle insured by the company. 

Colorado Farm Bureau

Colorado Farm Bureau is part of the Farm Bureau network of companies. It offers drivers the following coverages: 

  • Personal liability
  • Medical payments
  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist bodily injury
  • Uninsured/underinsured motorist property damage
  • Physical damage
  • Collision
  • Comprehensive

Colorado Springs, Denver, and Aurora drivers can save money through discounts for good students, low mileage drivers, multiple vehicles, and drivers with good driving records. If you bundle your home and auto policies, there are additional savings.

Colorado Insurance Demographics

Colorado has a high average income which correlates with higher Colorado auto insurance prices. Unfortunately, the state’s crime also plays a factor, and vehicle theft is rampant. Colorado’s median age range of 15-19 consists of inexperienced drivers who have higher insurance rates due to their age.

  • Crime Rates: Colorado ranks first in vehicle thefts in the country. In 2019, the state saw a reported $189 million in losses. It’s also the third-highest state for property theft. 
  • Average Household Income: The average household income for Colorado is $100,933. 
  • Median Age Range: The median age in Colorado is 36.9, while the median age range is 15-19. 
  • Education: Colorado has an educated population, as 26.05% of its residents hold a Bachelor’s degree. 

Common Risk Factors In Colorado

Colorado drivers have several risks that affect their insurance rates. Of all of the drivers on Colorado roads, a high 16.3% are uninsured, more than the national average of 12.6%. Colorado also features its share of natural disasters, including fires, floods, and hailstorms. It’s one of the states most at risk for natural disasters and sees damages of $464 million on average each year. 

Auto Insurance Laws In Colorado

Colorado has strict car insurance laws and heavily penalizes drivers failing to follow their requirements. The state requires every driver to carry liability insurance and mandates specific amounts for minimum coverage. A variety of optional Colorado car insurance coverages can help protect your vehicle in case of an accident

What are the minimum car insurance requirements in Colorado?

The minimum Colorado car insurance laws require all drivers to carry $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident in bodily injury. Property damage requirements are $15,000 per accident. If you finance your car, your lender may require full coverage. 

Am I required to carry uninsured motorist coverage in Colorado?

No. Uninsured motorist coverage is optional in Colorado. Your insurer must offer this coverage to you, but you aren’t obligated to buy it. 

Colorado SR-22 policies

Colorado requires an SR-22 for license reinstatement. If your license was suspended or revoked, you must file an SR-22 with the Colorado Division of Motor Vehicles. The SR-22 certifies you meet the minimum requirements for Colorado car insurance. 

What happens if my vehicle isn’t properly insured in Colorado?

You may face harsh penalties if you don’t meet the minimum requirements for Colorado auto insurance. Driving in Colorado without insurance is subject to a misdemeanor for “Failure to Hold Insurance. ” The charge may include up to $1,000 in fees, jail time, and an eight-month license suspension. Other penalties include four points on your license and up to 40 hours of community service. 

Does Colorado accept digital insurance cards?

Yes. Colorado accepts digital insurance cards as proof of insurance

How Much Does Car Insurance In Colorado Cost?

The average annual Colorado car insurance rate is $1,435 for minimum coverage and $2,198 for full coverage. Your policy rate will vary based on age, gender, location, and the insurance company. The high-density cities such as Boulder and Denver typically have higher insurance rates due to the increased risk of vehicle theft and damage. However, smaller Colorado cities like Fruitvale offer cheap rates under $200 a year. 

Average Cost of Car Insurance In Colorado By City

The most expensive areas in Colorado for car insurance are also popular vacation destinations. Drivers in areas such as Aurora and Colorado Springs see more vehicle theft and accidents overall, which increases insurance rates. 

CityAverage Colorado Car Insurance CostDifference From Colorado Average
Colorado Springs$2,1357%
Fort Collins$1,755-14%

Average Cost of Car Insurance In Colorado By Company

You should shop around and compare rates for the best deal. Rates for Colorado car insurance from consumer favorites like Geico, State Farm, and AllState may differ widely. Look at all of your options for minimum and full coverage.

Car Insurance CompanyAverage Liability-Only Premium (Annually)Average Full-Coverage Premium (Annually)
Colorado Farm Bureau Insurance$275$1,415
State Farm$410$1,520

Average Cost of Car Insurance In Colorado By Age

Coloradans aged 16 to 20 can expect to pay higher rates than older drivers. Insurers consider young drivers a higher risk for accidents, so young motorists will pay as much as $6,955 a year for full-coverage insurance in Colorado. Your premium drops with age. 

AgeAverage Full-Coverage Premium (Annually)
Age 18$4,030
Age 19$3,640
Age 20$3,400
Age 22$3,085
Age 25$2,470
Age 40$2,020

Average Cost of Car Insurance In Colorado By Gender

Insurance companies consider gender when they calculate your Colorado auto insurance premium. It’s common for male drivers to pay slightly higher rates, as men are viewed as riskier drivers.

GenderAverage Full-Coverage Premium (Annually)

Average Cost of Car Insurance In Colorado By Credit Score

There’s a correlation between low credit drivers and their likelihood of filing claims. Many insurers consider driver credit scores to determine a premium.

Credit ScoreAverage Annual Premium
Fair $2,325
Very Good$1,510

Average Cost of Car Insurance In Colorado By Driving Record

How you drive influences your rates for car insurance in Colorado. Careful drivers typically enjoy lower premiums than drivers with poor driving records. A single speeding ticket may increase your premium by 20%, while an accident may increase it by 39%. 

Driving IncidentAverage Full-Coverage Premium (Annually)
Speeding ticket$2,415

What Optional Colorado Auto Insurance Coverages Should You Consider?

Several policy options are available for Colorado car insurance drivers. These coverages expand your protection in case of an accident or injury while driving. 

  • Collision Coverage: If you collide with a vehicle or object, which damages your car, this coverage pays for the repair. 
  • Comprehensive Coverage: When Colorado’s severe weather or natural disasters damages your vehicle, Comprehensive coverage protects you.
  • Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Coverage: If you’re involved in a hit-and-run or get in an accident with an uninsured/underinsured driver in Colorado, this insurance offers protection. 
  • Medical Payments Coverage: Medical Payments helps with copays and deductibles for drivers and passengers if you’re in an accident. 

What Auto Insurance Discounts To Look For In Colorado

If you’re a driver in Colorado, auto insurance discounts may be available based on your vehicle’s safety features or mileage. Colorado insurers offer a variety of discounts. However, you may need to request them. Typical discounts in Colorado include a good student discount, mileage-based savings, and reduced premiums after a defensive driving class. 

Colorado Car Insurance FAQs

Are car insurance rates high in Colorado?

Car insurance rates in Colorado are slightly higher than the national average. 

How much is car insurance a month in Colorado?

Minimum car insurance costs an annual $1,435 for minimum coverage and $2,198. Rates vary by driver and insurance company.

What is the average cost of car insurance in Colorado Springs?

Colorado Springs has some of the most expensive insurance rates in the state.  The average cost is $1,903 a year.

What is considered full-coverage in Colorado?

Full coverage car insurance in Colorado is any policy that offers more than the state’s minimum requirement of  $25,000 in bodily injury coverage per person, up to $50,000 per accident, and $15,000 in property damage coverage. Comprehensive and collision insurance is included in full coverage. 

Is Denver car insurance expensive?

Denver car insurance is nearly $2,000 a year and is much higher than the state’s average annual cost of $1,757.

How To Find Cheap Car Insurance In Colorado

Before you buy Colorado car insurance, research the insurers available in your area. Make sure you look at policies that meet the minimum requirements for Colorado and compare rates from several providers to find the best deal.