Top Homeowners Insurance in California


WRITTEN BY: Mark Romero

UPDATED: SEPTEMBER 22, 2022 | 3 MIN READ

At $1,031 per year, the average home insurance policy in California costs about 35% less than the national average. To help you find great home insurance, we’ve compiled the best California homeowner’s insurance companies along with loads of helpful info to help you make an informed buying decision.

Best California Home Insurance Companies

Wondering how various California home insurance companies compare? Whether you’re concerned most about costs, customer service, or coverage options, we’ve chosen the best homeowners insurance options for you.

Overall Best Home Insurance In California

state farm insurance

Not only is State Farm a well-known company with a long history of customer satisfaction, it has a J.D. Power Score of 835/1,000 and an “excellent” rating from AM Best. The company’s average annual premium for $250K dwelling coverage is $764, which is $320 less than the state’s average.

California Home Insurance With the Best Coverage Options

allstate insurance

The home insurance company with the best coverage options in California is Allstate. It offers a number of optional coverage add-ons, including earthquake insurance, flood insurance, and water backup insurance. Of course, the company offers all of the typical home insurance coverage options too, such as dwelling and other structures coverage. 

Best Value Home Insurance In California

Home insurance rates in California vary depending on the company. USAA sells the cheapest home insurance in California at $484 below the state average. Those that do not qualify for USAA coverage should look to Allstate.  Its average annual premium of $764 is $320 less than the state’s average amount.

California Home Insurance With the Best Customer Service

AIG Home Insurance Logo

Those seeking top-tier customer service should consider AIG. The company had zero complaints in California registered with the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) Complaint Index for 2021. It also ranked 830/1,000 for overall satisfaction in J.D. Power’s June 2022 consumer survey.

California Home Insurance That’s Best For Bundling

If you’re aiming to save, consider purchasing your home and auto policies from the same company. Allstate has the best discount, with homeowners saving up to 25% when they purchase an auto policy. Allstate also offers a 10% welcome discount for new customers along with safety and payment discounts.

California State Demographics that Impact Your Home Insurance Premiums

Home insurance costs vary depending on various factors, including age and location. Below are some of the state’s demographics that could affect your home insurance premiums.

  • Average Home Value:  The average home value in California is $699,876, with 13,103,114 homes and apartments in the state.
  • Crime Rates: California’s violent crime rate is 4.40 per 1,000 residents. The state’s overall property crime rate is 21.30 per 1,000 residents. 
  • Average Household Income: The median household income in California is $78,672, over 21% more than the national average household income of $64,994.
  • Median Age Range: People over 65 make up 14.3% of California’s population. However, most of the population falls into the 35–54 age range (26.1% of the population, to be exact).
  • Education: About 84% of Californians are high school graduates, while almost 35% have college degrees.

Is Home Insurance Required In California?

California doesn’t require you to carry homeowners insurance, but your mortgage company might. If your lender does not require it, it’s still wise to take the steps to protect your home and your personal items from unforeseen events. If you’re worried about the cost, you can use a home insurance calculator to get a fairly good estimate.

Common Home Risk Factors In California

California’s biggest home insurance risks are fire, earthquake, and flood damage. With these common risk factors, homeowners need to make sure that a homeowner’s insurance policy will cover the full value of a home in the event of a total loss.

While your standard home insurance policy includes coverage for fire damage, it may be worth adding additional coverage to extend it. Some optional coverages California residents should consider are earthquake insurance, flood insurance, and scheduled personal property insurance.

Earthquake Insurance

California law requires home insurance companies to offer earthquake insurance to their policyholders. Unfortunately, most companies’ earthquake insurance excludes any damage caused by earthquake shaking.

This is where the California Earthquake Authority (CEA) comes into play.

25 different residential insurers sell CEA policies. You can’t purchase it directly from the CEA. If you’re insured by one of the 25 providers, you simply ask them to include a CEA earthquake policy with your home insurance.

If you aren’t insured by one of the 25 insurers, you need to purchase your earthquake insurance as a separate policy. The companies that handle CEA earthquake insurance include:

Companies in California that Handle CEA Earthquake Insurance

  1. ACA Insurance
  2. Allstate
  3. Amica Mutual Insurance Company
  4. Armed Forces Insurance Exchange
  5. ASI
  6. Automobile Club of Southern California
  7. California FAIR Plan
  8. Commerce West
  9. CSAA-AAA Northern California
  10. Encompass
  11. Farmers Insurance Group
  12. Foremost
  13. Homesite
  14. Hyundai Marine & Fire Insurance Policy
  15. Liberty Mutual
  16. Liberty Mutual Group Business Insurance Agriculture/Farm
  17. MAPFRE
  18. Mercury
  19. Nationwide
  20. Nationwide Private Client
  21. Progressive
  22. SafeCo
  23. State Farm
  24. Toggle
  25. USAA

Flood Insurance

Standard home insurance policies don’t include coverage for flood damage. If you’re in a high-risk area, it’s important to consider adding flood insurance to your home insurance policy.

Flood insurance is available private insurance or as a National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) policy, which is underwritten by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA).

Insurance Providers that Sell NFIP Flood Insurance Policies in California

  1. Allstate
  2. American Commerce
  3. American National Property & Casualty
  4. American Strategic Insurance Corp
  5. Assurant
  6. CSAA Insurance Exchange
  7. Farmers Insurance Group
  8. Hartford Fire Insurance Co.
  9. Hartford Underwriters Insurance Co.
  10. Liberty Mutal Fire Insurance Company
  11. National General Insurance Company
  12. NFIP Direct Servicing Agent
  13. Occidental Fire & Casualty
  14. Pacific Specialty Insurance Company
  15. Philadelphia Indemnity Insurance Co.
  16. Privilege Underwriters
  17. QBE Insurance Corporation
  18. Selective Insurance Company Of America
  19. Universal North America Insurance Company
  20. USAA
  21. Wright National Flood Insurance Co.

Scheduled Personal Property Insurance

Personal property coverage limits specific high-value items, such as jewelry, artwork, and electronics. To ensure your property is completely covered, you should schedule valuable items on your home policy. Keep in mind, that a scheduled personal property endorsement may require an appraisal. 

How Much Does Home Insurance In California Cost?

In California, home insurance costs are based on city and region-specific variables, like fire risk, crime rate, number of filed claims in your area, and more. 

Los Angeles is the most expensive city in California for home insurance, with an average price of $1,385 per year. The cheapest home insurance rates are available in Oxnard, where a typical term costs around $722.

The below table shows the cost of California home insurance by city, with average costs ranging from $925 to $1,385.

Cost of Home Insurance In California By City

In California, home insurance costs vary from city to city. The table below shows how the average cost in the state’s five largest cities compares to California’s overall average.

City Average California
Home Insurance Cost
Difference From
California Average
Los Angeles$1,38534%
Oakland$1,0714%
Sacramento$925-10%
San Diego$974-6%
San Francisco$1,033Same

Companies That Offer Fire-Hardened Homes Discounts

Fire-hardened homes are built using specific materials and installation techniques to increase heat resistance and damage from embers and wildfire flames. The following home insurance companies offer fire-hardened home discounts in California.

  • Allstate
  • American Modern Home Insurance
  • ASI Select Insurance
  • California Automobile Insurance Company
  • Crestbrook Insurance Company
  • CSAA Insurance Exchange
  • Falls Lake Fire and Casualty
  • Occidental Fire & Casualty Company of North Carolina
  • State Farm
  • The Cincinnati Insurance Company
  • California FAIR Plan
  • Chubb Group
  • Federal Insurance Company
  • Pacific Indemnity Company
  • Vigilant Insurance Company
  • USAA
  • Garrison Property and Casualty Insurance Company
  • United Services Automobile Association

California Home Insurance FAQs

How much is the average home insurance in California?

The average home insurance policy in California is around $1,031 per year. This is approximately 35% less than the national average. 

Is homeowner’s insurance required in California?

Homeowner’s insurance isn’t a requirement in California. However, most mortgage companies and lenders require anyone paying on their homes to carry home insurance.

Why is homeowner’s insurance so expensive in California?

The median cost of homeowner’s insurance in California is about 35% less than the national average. However, it can be more expensive in areas prone to wildfires and/or earthquakes and with high crime rates.

How much is fire insurance in California?

Fire insurance doesn’t cost extra in California. It’s included with the cost of your homeowner’s insurance policy. The average cost of California home insurance is $1,031 annually as of June 2022.

Is wildfire insurance mandatory in California?

No, wildfire insurance isn’t mandatory in California. However, most mortgage companies and lenders require you to have home insurance that includes wildfire coverage.

How To Purchase California Home Insurance

Home insurance quotes require quite a bit of information, so before you get started, you should know:

  • Year your house was built
  • Age of your roof
  • Roof style
  • The exterior finish of the home
  • What improvements you’ve made
  • Updates that could increase the home’s value

It’s also important to have a general idea of the value of your personal belongings and a list of any high-value items with their appraisal amounts.

Once you’ve gathered the needed information, get several home insurance quotes online to compare coverages and rates.