Cheapest Car Insurance in Florida for 2023


WRITTEN BY: Julia Matseikovich

UPDATED: JANUARY 18, 2023 | 2 MIN READ

When it comes to driving in Florida, here’s what you need to know

Florida’s average car insurance rates are nearly 60% higher than the national average, with 16 million licensed drivers. Auto insurance in Florida can cost anywhere between $1,100 and $2,400 per year. Keep reading to learn how to save money on your auto insurance costs in Florida.

The best auto insurance companies in Florida

Cheapest Florida Car Insurance Company: GEICO

The cheapest car insurance carrier is GEICO for policies that meet Florida’s minimum insurance requirements at an average of $34 a month. State Farm isn’t far behind at $50. 

PROS
  • Many savings options available
  • Affordable rates for drivers with poor credit and speeding tickets on their record
  • Good customer satisfaction ratings
  • Offers accident forgiveness
CONS
  • Above-average rates for drivers with DUIs
  • Doesn't offer new car replacement, rideshare coverage, or a vanishing deductible
  • Lower-than-average bundling discount for people with GEICO auto and home policies

Company That Provides the Best Customer Service: State Farm

When it comes to customer service, State Farm is a clear winner. The company’s J.D. Power customer satisfaction score ranks 848 out of 1,000.

PROS
  • Easy claims process
  • High customer satisfaction ratings from J.D. Power
  • A++ Financial Strength rating from AM Best
  • Lots of discounts and coverage options available
CONS
  • No option to add gap insurance to your policy
  • Premiums are on the higher side

Company With the Best Premium-Reducing Programs: Allstate

Allstate is one of the most affordable carriers in Florida. They have the best premium reduction options for drivers. The insurer features discounts for driving habits, car features, and even good grades. After you’ve been accident or claim free for at least three years, you can get a good driver discount.

PROS
  • Lots of savings options available, including teen driver discounts
  • Several digital tools available for policy management and filing claims
  • Company has strong financial stability
  • Offers rideshare coverage in several states
CONS
  • Some coverage options aren't available in all states
  • Average rates are often higher than the national average

Best Local or Regional Auto Insurance Carriers In Florida

If you’re looking for the cheaper car insurance in Florida, it’s important to consider smaller insurance carriers too.

United Automobile Insurance Company

Founded in 1989, United Automobile Insurance Company (UAIC) is regional car insurance for Florida. Their specialty is high-risk car insurance for drivers with blemishes on the record, and their products offer a good option for Florida struggling to find insurance.

UAIC offers SR22, FR44, non-owner car insurance, plus standard policies such as bodily injury, collision, and comprehensive. The carrier features affordable rates and an efficient, quick claims process. UAIC offers discounts to its members with varying rates.

Esurance Insurance

Esurance Insurance is an Allstate company. They offer car insurance for Floridians at an affordable price. Esurance includes coverages that protect you, your car, and your assets. Coverage options include collision, comprehensive, emergency roadside assistance, rental car coverage, and medical payments.

Thanks to the abundance of coverage options Esurance Insurance offers, you can get on the road without worry. Discounts may apply for multiple vehicles, advance quotes, and full payments.

Horace Mann Insurance

Horace Mann Insurance offers car insurance exclusively to Floridians in the education field. If you teach or work in a Florida school, you may purchase car insurance through Horace Mann Insurance. Car insurance coverages offered include collision, comprehensive, emergency roadside service, and rental reimbursement.

They also offer protection, including liability and uninsured/underinsured motorists. In addition to the preferred rates Horace Mann Insurance offers to educators, the insurer also offers discounts. You can save with multiple cars if your premium is deducted from payroll and other options.  

Common risk factors that impact rates for Florida drivers

While nicknamed the Sunshine State, Florida has its share of natural disasters. The high risk for tropical storms, hurricanes, hail, and other severe storms leads to increased claims in Florida car insurance.

Another high-risk factor for Florida’s drivers is the state’s uninsured motorists, with 20% of drivers without the minimum insurance requirements, the highest rate in the United States. As uninsured drivers get on the road and cause accidents, insured drivers can pay higher prices. 

Auto Insurance Laws In Florida

Auto insurance laws in Florida differ from other states. First, Florida car insurance regulations require drivers have personal injury protection, not the bodily injury liability (BIL) coverage most states require. It’s also a no-fault state. The state has low minimum requirements for auto insurance and several penalties for driving without proof of insurance

What are the minimum car insurance requirements in Florida?

All vehicles within Florida require two types of insurance: Personal Injury Protection and Property Damage Liability. The minimum coverage for both is $10,000. These are the standard vehicle requirements. 

Am I required to carry uninsured motorist coverage in Florida?

No. Florida car insurance regulations don’t mandate uninsured motorist coverage. 

Florida SR22 and FR44 policies

Florida drivers convicted of violations, like driving while uninsured or driving without a license, may need to purchase an SR22 or an FR44. These certificates show that a driver carries the state’s minimum liability coverage. Florida requires drivers to obtain these for reinstatement. 

FR44 is applicable in Florida, though not in other states. It’s for showing you have more than the bare minimum the SR22 requires. If you have a DUI or DWI, you’re high risk and will need an FR44. 

Is Florida a no-fault state?

Florida is no-fault, which means drivers file with their insurance company if they’re injured, even if they didn’t cause the accident. 

What happens if my vehicle isn’t adequately insured in Florida?

If registering your vehicle in Florida, you need adequate insurance. This means you need at least a liability-only car insurance policy. Driving without insurance or the minimum amount of coverage may result in: 

  • License and plate suspension
  • Reinstatement fees of $150 for the first violation, with any subsequent violations fined at $250 and $500

As Florida is a no-fault state, injured drivers must file claims with their insurance companies. Mounting medical bills and a possible lawsuit may result from a severe accident. 

Does Florida accept digital insurance cards?

Yes. Florida accepts digital insurance cards.

How Much Does Car Insurance In Florida Cost?

The average monthly cost for Florida auto insurance is $284, higher than the national average of $233. A premium depends on the driver’s age, vehicle, gender, marital status, driving history, and other elements. 

How much you pay for Florida car insurance also depends on where you live within the state. Areas more susceptible to hurricanes and extreme weather will have higher rates, and so do cities with higher crime. Panama City is one of the cheapest cities for car insurance, while Miami offers some of Florida’s highest rates.

Average Cost of Car Insurance In Florida By City

The cost of Florida car insurance varies by region, with the Florida average at $2,962 a year, or $247 a month. Jacksonville, the most populated city in the state, features one of the lowest average Florida car insurance costs. The smaller city of Miami has a higher rate, likely thanks to its higher household income and a greater number of luxury vehicles. 

CityAverage Monthly
Car Insurance Cost
Difference From
Florida Average
Jacksonville$245-4%
Miami$34534%
Orlando$2653%
Tampa$33531%
St. Petersburg$2809%

Average Cost of Car Insurance In Florida By Company

State Farm offers the lowest average full-coverage insurance premiums for Florida car insurance at just $3,323 a year. The highest costs for Florida are from Progressive, with an average annual $7,029 premium. 

Car Insurance CompanyAverage Full-Coverage Premium (Annually)*
Allstate$4,783
Progressive$7,029
GEICO$5,133
State Farm$3,323

*The rates in the table reference a single female, age 25 with one car, one violation, and one at-fault accident within the past three years.

Average Cost of Car Insurance In Florida By Age

Florida has a high number of younger drivers and older (65+) drivers. Rates for auto insurance in Florida is higher for these two population groups, especially compared to drivers aged 30-60.

AgeAverage Full-Coverage Premium (Annually)
Age 16$4,345
Age 18$8,170
Age 20$5,730
Age 25$3,360
Age 30$2,960
Age 40$2,365
Age 50$2,480
Age 60$2,400
Age 70$2,630

Average Cost of Car Insurance In Florida By Gender

Car insurance rates vary in Florida by gender, with women paying more. This disparity appears across the country, but Florida has the highest difference.

Average Full-Coverage Premium (Annually)
Male$2,340
Female$2,395

Average Cost of Car Insurance In Florida By Credit Score

Across the board, Florida car insurance prices are higher than most states. The difference can be seen in the average credit score and associated premium. Drivers with low credit scores are more inclined to file claims and thus will pay higher rates.

PoorAverageGoodExcellent
National Average$3,875$1,865$1,675$1,490
Florida Average$5,820$3,035$2,365$2,165

Average Cost of Car Insurance In Florida By Driving Record

Florida drivers with a good driving history will have a lower premium as the accident risk is lower than someone with repeated violations. These violations can affect your premium rates for up to five years. 

Driving IncidentAverage Full-Coverage Premium (Annually)% Increase In Average Full-Coverage Premium
Clean Driving Record$2,365
Speeding Ticket$3,35542%
Accident$3,66555%
DUI/DWI$4,55092%

What Optional Florida Auto Insurance Coverages Should You Consider?

The minimum insurance coverage Florida requires doesn’t cover much, and drivers may opt for additional auto insurance coverage. Florida doesn’t require BIL coverage, but it can help, especially if a driver is seriously injured. 

  • Collision: If your car is involved in a crash, this coverage helps with your vehicle costs. 
  • Comprehensive: When a vehicle is damaged by a covered peril such as weather, theft, or hitting an animal, this coverage offers protection.
  • Uninsured Motorist Coverage: One in five Florida drivers is uninsured. This coverage pays drivers if they’re hit by a driver and aren’t at fault or if their existing coverage can’t pay the total medical bills.
  • Bodily Injury Liability: If the policyholder causes injury or death in a car accident, the injured may request compensation through this policy. 
  • Medical Payments: If a driver or their passenger(s) are injured, this coverage helps with medical bills associated with the accident.
  • Roadside Assistance: This coverage pays for towing, battery jumping, and other roadside emergencies.

What Auto Insurance Discounts To Look For In Florida

Policyholders in Florida may be eligible for certain discounts on their car insurance. Savings range from 1% to 30% based on various criteria. Even younger drivers can save with insurer’s discounts for students with good grades. You may opt for a usage-based deal for discounts based on how much you drive. Each insurance company offers discounts, so shopping around for the best offers is best.

FAQs

Is it expensive to insure a car in Florida?

Florida car insurance rates are over 40% higher than the national average. 

Who is cheaper than GEICO in Florida?

State Farm is the winner of affordability in Florida car insurance rates. The insurance agency has the cheapest overall rates at $164 monthly.

What is considered full-coverage in Florida?

Full coverage auto insurance is another term for the state minimum coverage. This is Personal Injury Protection (PIP) and Property Damage Liability (PDL) for $10,000 each. 

Is bodily injury required in Florida?

Florida car insurance laws don’t require bodily injury for personal vehicles. Any vehicle registered as a taxi needs $125,000 per person in bodily injury liability coverage. 

Who pays for medical bills in a car accident in Florida?

The driver is responsible for their medical bills and must file a claim with their insurance company, even if not at fault. The PIP coverage pays for 80% of the medical bills, after which additional coverage (if you have it) or your medical insurance applies. 

How to Purchase Car Insurance in Florida

Do you want to purchase Florida car insurance? You should start with a reasonable quote for Florida’s best auto insurance rates. Every quote depends on your gender, age, whether you’re married, and other factors. It’s best to shop and compare through auto insurance quotes